Sunday, April 26, 2009

The Exorcism of Emily Rose (2005)


"Demons exist whether you believe in them or not," says the priest at the center of The Exorcism of Emily Rose. Yes, and you could also say that demons do not exist whether you believe in them or not, because belief by definition stands outside of proof. If you can prove it, you don't need to believe it.

Such truths are at the center of this intriguing and perplexing movie, which is based on the true story of a priest who was accused of murder after a teenage girl died during an exorcism. If the priest is correct and the girl was possessed by a demon, he is innocent. If the authorities called by the prosecution are correct, she died of psychotic epileptic disorder, and the priest created complications leading to her death. If, on the other hand, exorcism theory is correct, drugs given to the girl to treat her "disorder" made her immune to exorcism and led to her death.

The movie is told through flashbacks from a courtroom, where Father Moore is on trial. He has been offered a deal (plead guilty to reckless endangerment and do six years of a 12-year sentence), but he refuses it: "I don't care about my reputation and I'm not afraid of jail. All I care about is telling Emily Rose's story." His lawyer Erin Bruner despairs, and yet admires him for his conviction. She herself does not believe in demons. The prosecutor, Ethan Thomas is a church goer and does presumably believe, but lawyers sometimes argue against what they believe to be true. That's their job.

And who is Emily Rose? As played by Jennifer Carpenter in a grueling performance, she is a college student who sees the faces of friends and strangers turn into demonic snarls. Her nightmares are haunting. She speaks in foreign languages. She loses an alarming amount of weight. She calls home for help, in tears. Her boyfriend can't reach her. The parish priest, Father Moore, is called in, and determines that an exorcism is indicated.

He has authorization from the archdiocese, but after he is charged with murder the church authorities order him to accept plea bargaining and create as little scandal for the church as possible. The church is curiously ambivalent about exorcism. It believes that the devil and his agents can be active in the world, it has a rite of exorcism, and it has exorcists. On the other hand, it is reluctant to certify possessions and authorize exorcisms, and it avoids publicity on the issue. It's like those supporters of Intelligent Design who privately believe in a literal interpretation of Genesis, but publicly distance themselves from it because that would undermine their plausibility in the wider world.


What is fascinating about The Exorcism of Emily Rose is that it asks a secular institution, the court, to decide a question that hinges on matters the court cannot have an opinion on. Either Emily was possessed by a demon and Father Moore did his best to save her, or she had a psychotic condition and he unwittingly did his best to kill her. The defense and the prosecution mount strong arguments and call persuasive witnesses, but in the end it all comes down to the personal beliefs of the jury. A juror who does not believe in demons must find the priest guilty, if perhaps sincere. A juror who does believe in demons must decide if Emily Rose was possessed, or misdiagnosed. In a case like this, during the jury selection, are you qualified or disqualified by believing one way or the other?

The film is fascinating in the way it makes legal and ethical issues seem as suspenseful as possession and exorcism.

The movie was directed by Scott Derrickson and written by Paul Harris Boardman and Derrickson. The screenplay is intelligent and open to occasional refreshing wit, as when prosecutor Ethan Thomas makes an objection to one witnesses' speculations about demonology. "On what grounds?" asks the judge (Mary Beth Hurt). "Oh...silliness," he says.

a scene from 'the exorcism of emily rose'

Somehow the movie really never takes off into the riveting fascination we expect in the opening scenes. Maybe it cannot; maybe it is too faithful to the issues it raises to exploit them. A movie like The Exorcist is a better film because it's a more limited one, which accepts demons and exorcists lock, stock and barrel, as its starting point. Certainly they're good showbiz. A film that keeps an open mind must necessarily lack a slam-dunk conclusion. In the end Emily Rose's story does get told, although no one can agree about what it means. You didn't ask, but in my opinion she was possessed, and it was science that killed her, not faith.

8/10

p.s There is a scene where Emily explains about a vision she had of the Virgin Mary and it was so touching it almost made me cry. The fact she sacrifced herself for the ignorance of man.

44 comments:

  1. ya know what... i wasn't totally impressed by this movie. i dunno why. it was just so blah. maybe bc i can't stand that anorexi actress in the movie. ugh!

    Gosh I miss commenting on your blog. Not blogging for a few days is so weird and I feel Like I missed stuffs.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well, the reality is that health care reform is actually going to affect everybody. Starting in 2014,Just Keto we're going to have a whole new set of health plans, and those plans have very rich benefits with lots of extra features that the existing plans today don't offer. So these new plans are going to be higher cost.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It's not the end of the world. If a woman doesn't have the financial ability or inclination to get collagen injections, there are alternative methods to enhance and keep the lips looking desirable. Lip Liner Tips

    ReplyDelete
  4. but what have out you do when you happen into the realization you occur to be great enough to take part in with the big children, or even for money? Whilst jumping the rifle and seeking to high-stakes cash tournaments may be some kind of little
    asikqq
    dewaqq
    sumoqq
    interqq
    pionpoker
    pelangiqq
    hobiqq
    paito warna
    http://192.254.236.33/hobiqq78/
    datahk 2019

    ReplyDelete
  5. Sleeping is one thing that many people don't think of when talking about health and beauty. Well, the truth is; if you are not having enough sleep, regardless of whether you are a kid or old fellow, you're going to lose all the freshness of your skin. FairyMines

    ReplyDelete
  6. Also note that a contractual ambiguity in a clause could hurt an artist, regardless of whether it is embedded in one of the artist's performance obligations, or even in one of the label's performance obligations! The moral?: List all performance obligations. Family of Thakurganj full movie download

    ReplyDelete
  7. What is the last and final path towards your healthy weight loss and quick Ultra Fast Keto Boost weight loss? Phase III of your healthy weight loss and quick weight loss journey is your intake of fluids. Ok, stop the presses!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Do you constantly get teased by family and friends for being a vegan? Many vegans have to suffer this day in and day out. So why not head to your recipe collection and find your tastiest mouth-watering vegan recipe that you have. Trendy Mumi

    ReplyDelete
  9. The male enhancement subject is within the group of what exactly is regarded as a 'controversial' discussion. One of the finest controversies, naturally, is regarding whether or not the products designed for male enhancement work. Regarding this aspect, the medical

    Bandox Extreme

    ReplyDelete
  10. 'high' enough to cause the manifestation of female sexual characteristics - but may be high enough to hinder the action of the male hormones in him. So we have yet again another set of male enhancement pills that work through this mechanism of antagonizing the above-normal

    Zylophin RX

    ReplyDelete
  11. to find out more information on all of the fitness tuning training techniques for a healthy weight loss and quick weight loss program listed in this article, as well as more advanced training methods, by clicking on my website's link below. You can join my free membership

    Iron Slim Keto

    ReplyDelete
  12. these devices can cost too much. Though they can help you achieve erection, the regular use of these devices may damage your blood vessels that can lead to permanent erectile dysfunction. Penis extenders of penis traction device provide better results in achieving

    Bioinvitagen

    ReplyDelete
  13. materials which glow when a current is applied, rather than relying on a backlight. This means that the monitors are much thinner and lighter, have an unmatched contrast ratio, colour reproduction and response time and can even be made flexible. Although this technology
    Best Portable Monitors


    ReplyDelete
  14. positions. What do they accomplish, deeper penetration, to help you get to that "special spot". If you were to take the initiative to enhance your male anatomy, there may be less of a need for these acrobatics and you achieve instant self esteem and your female lover will thank you again and again and again.



    Nano XL

    ReplyDelete
  15. I was always fed well prepared, nutritious meals by my parents. I just ate too much. I didn't even realize I was doing this. During my childhood I became used to eating a certain amount of food. I became an habitual overeater. I kept overeating, automatically, and never thought about changing my behavior. Yet, I never did become morbidly obese. I simply continued to carry around the extra 25 to 30 pounds that I always had carried around.

    KetoPower Boost

    ReplyDelete
  16. Also, I noticed that when I stopped my crash diet, my old eating habits returned. Because I hadn't gone about exercising in order to replace any of my depleted muscle tissue, I easily gained back all the weight that I had lost. Not only did all the lost weight return, but I also

    Insta Keto

    ReplyDelete
  17. Fasting: While fasting has real influence in a few eating methodologies, it is by and large not prescribed for safe weight loss.


    Keto Guru

    ReplyDelete
  18. o Permanent weight loss is not about finding a quick fix diet, but making a commitment to life style changes that include nutrition and exercise
    o Any weight loss program you choose must pass the "Can I eat that way for the rest of my life?" test,

    Diamond Keto 247

    ReplyDelete
  19. your friends. The same product simply might not work for your needs, in the same way. Also, some penile enhancement items, such as the pills, don't suit all the men who buy them. Therefore, gather more complete information concerning the product you need to use

    KSZ Male Enhancement

    ReplyDelete
  20. will see the change in the cleint. Today, I utilize Remotivation therapy in all of my programs in my facility. This increases their self-esteem and socialization, which provides the opportunity for the individual to focus on something other than their illness. After a few sessions the clients are more social and talkative. Remotivation therapy is a wonderful tool


    genbrain

    ReplyDelete
  21. These categorizations will assist in making it easier to sort through the deluge of male enhancement advertisements with more clarity. Specifically, it can be helpful to know what male enhancement options are available and what is possible. Just as there are a wide


    Andezal Male Enhancement

    ReplyDelete
  22. Physical Adaptation Our bodies adapt themselves to our calorie consumption and physical activity levels. When we begin an exercise regime, our body is required to make several changes to adjust to changing workloads. Our muscles have to rebuild themselves and this requires many calories. But, over time the body finishes adapting and burns less calories for
    Insta keto reviews

    ReplyDelete
  23. sexual organs). Depending on this way of thinking, the prevailing ultimate view would be that the penile enhancement pills essentially don't function - which the folks today selling options are con artists who're only looking to fleece males and ladies off their hard gained cash.

    centallus rx male enhancement

    ReplyDelete
  24. Fasting: While fasting has significant influence in a few eating regimens, it is for the most part not prescribed for safe weight reduction.


    Tier 2 Keto Reviews

    ReplyDelete
  25. The perfect Christmas tree is hard to find, particularly when you are tramping around the mountains instead of a tree farm. But what would Christmas be without a tree? And out west, there could only be one type of tree suitable for Christmas-a pine tree. The tree is the center of
    modern Christmas tree


    ReplyDelete
  26. If you know that your daily caloric target is good and you have absolutely no calorie creep, then you should increase your cardio.


    Velocity Trim Keto

    ReplyDelete
  27. made meals, are of the diet A variety covered above. They're easy to follow but destined for failure, long term. They all fail the "Can I eat that way for the rest of my life?" test, unless you really think you can eat cookies and shakes for the rest of your life...Bottom line here is, if the nutritional approach you use to lose weight, be it from a book, a class, a clinic, or an e-

    Instant Keto

    ReplyDelete
  28. Second, it must be a plan that incorporates both diet AND exercise. Merely changing the way you eat is not enough. And a weight loss program that includes exercise does require a commitment and will take time out of your schedule to devote to your weight loss program.


    Keto Pro Avis

    ReplyDelete
  29. As we all know, matter cannot be created nor destroyed, so when you exercise and diet fat is not simply "disappearing" off your body. What occurs is a form change, just like water and steam. The glucose and sugar that is harnessed from carbohydrates are the first fuel sources.

    activate keto

    ReplyDelete
  30. Male Impotence treatment you choose, prescription drugs or a natural male enhancement product, always remember to review the ingredients and dosages carefully. Different products and supplements work differently on different individuals so your results may vary from others. Of course, overall good health is important to good healthy sexual living.

    PWX Male Enhancement

    https://www.facebook.com/events/2452898138280750/
    https://www.facebook.com/pwxmale
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZXfcqQBLA6I&t=1s
    https://medium.com/@jj524938/pwx-male-enhancement-is-a-natural-diet-dc303cb8562d

    ReplyDelete
  31. meaning that they produce no side effects. With not side effects and their completely healthy ingredients this means you do not have to worry about things like getting dizzy, groggy, tired,etc... when taking these supplements. Also, one thing to remember about male enhancement supplements is that they are much more affordable than prescription medications.

    Verocity Male Enhancement

    ReplyDelete
  32. delivery method doesn't necessarily indicate a change in the actual ingredient formula. A well known example of a medication patch is the nicotine patch used to stop smoking. The increasing availability of male enhancement formulas in patch form means that men who aren't able to swallow a pill or capsule are still able to gain the benefits of certain male


    KSX Male Enhancement

    ReplyDelete
  33. start taking pain killers after a moderate injury or because of a severe injury in an automobile accident, fall or for post surgical pain. Physical dependence on a drug suggests that sudden stopping of the drug may result in negative consequences.

    CBD Miracle Pain Patch

    ReplyDelete
  34. Generally speaking, the higher a patient's pre-surgery weight or BMI, the more excess weight the patient can lose after surgery. However, recipients of weight-loss surgery with less excess body weight will eventually come closer to their ideal weight when committed to long-term diet and exercise. Also, resolution or improvement in obesity-related diseases can occur with even

    Alpha Femme Keto Genix

    ReplyDelete
  35. These categorizations will assist in making it easier to sort through the deluge of male enhancement advertisements with more clarity. Specifically, it can be helpful to know what male enhancement options are available and what is possible. Just as there are a wide variety of male enhancement options there are equally diverse opinions on whether male
    Superior Flux Male Enhancement

    ReplyDelete
  36. interfere with the body's use of most nutrients. If soil can grow crops, the food produced is nutritious. When soil lacks minerals, plants don't grow properly and may not produce their potential yield. Growing area does affect a food's iodine and selenium contents.Renegade Keto

    ReplyDelete
  37. This actually has a common name. We in the fitness industry call this the F.I.T.T principle. Beyond these basics which are usually associated with the exercise components of your program there will also be nutritional requirements to any quality weight loss program that fit perfectly into the same acronym:


    Vibrant Enhanced Keto

    ReplyDelete

  38. toe is a hinge joint, designed to only move up and down. When you force it outward, but still demand it function normally, it has long term degenerative effects.
    room? Can the piggies wiggle? They should be able to.
    Best Women Crossfit Shoes


    ReplyDelete
  39. Directly against the view of the mainstream medical community, of course, is the view of the manufactures of these male-enhancement pills, and their regular users: who hold the opinion that these products indeed do work (wonders sometimes) in enhancing the size of
    Biovirexagen

    ReplyDelete
  40. The most effective program in the world is useless if you don't do it. I know this first-hand. I've program you can invest in is one you will participate in, be challenged by and finish. I can name at least a hundred weight loss programs off the top of my head that have produced amazing

    Ketophin BHB

    ReplyDelete
  41. Loose skin not only occurs with a massive weight loss but also with natural body occurrences such as pregnancy. This is because once your body stretches through weight gain or through pregnancy; your skin loses its elasticity. First patients come in to talk about weight-loss and
    Keto Crush

    ReplyDelete
  42. Tier 2 Keto Actually use that fat to destroy additional fat in entire body. Fat doesn't make you fat. Best type will really help you burn off flab. So always be on the watch for the wrong kind of fat.
    https://www.wellnessketoz.com/tier-2-keto/

    ReplyDelete
  43. Customer Helpline Australia purported losses attributed to fraud coupled with displaying tangible proof in their efforts to detect and investigate fraud, as well as now not paying fraudulent claims. Five. Insurers are victims of health care fraud Insurers, as a ordinary route of business, provide reports on fraud to offer themselves as sufferers of fraud through deviant carriers and suppliers. It's far
    https://customerhelplineaustralia.com/

    ReplyDelete
  44. Keto Meal Plan worker advantages research Institute located that human beings enrolled in HSA-eligible excessive-deductible fitness plans were an awful lot less happy with many aspects in their fitness care than adults in more complete plans human beings in these plans allocate enormous quantities of income to their fitness care, mainly those who have poorer health or decrease incomes. The survey also observed that adults in excessive-deductible health plans are far more likely to put off or avoid getting needed care, or to skip medicinal drugs, because of the fee. Issues are especially suggested among people with poorer .


    http://ketomealplan.reviews/

    ReplyDelete